False pro-Palestinian narratives
The article challenges several pro-Palestinian narratives by presenting historical arguments that question the displacement of Arabs by European Jewish settlers, the roots of Palestinian nationalism, and the reasons for Zionist military success in 1948. It argues that Arab migration to the region was significant, Palestinian national identity emerged relatively late, and internal divisions weakened Arab efforts. The piece also disputes claims of overwhelming foreign military support for Zionists and highlights lack of unified Arab invasion forces.
- ▪Jews were the majority in Jerusalem by the 1850s, and Jewish communities reestablished themselves after the Crusades.
- ▪Palestinian nationalism did not emerge as a distinct movement until the 1960s, with earlier political consciousness being largely pan-Arabist.
- ▪The Grand Mufti opposed the 1937 Peel Commission partition plan and suppressed Arab support for it, allegedly orchestrating the killing of 1,000 Arabs who were open to the proposal.
- ▪Local Arab communities often sought accommodations with Zionists, and the Arab Liberation Army struggled due to lack of local support and supply issues.
- ▪Lebanon did not send troops in the 1948 war, and the Arab forces were not a unified front against the Zionists.
Opening excerpt (first ~120 words) tap to expand
There are many historical myths related to the Palestinians promoted by anti-Zionist forces. Without these myths, many of the pro-Palestinian narratives crumble and Zionist positions are strengthened. Myth 1: European Jews were settlers who migrated to the land of Israel at the end of the 19th century, displacing Arabs who had resided there for centuries. Recommended Stories Congress should pass Red Tape Elimination Act to lower prescription drug costs The keffiyeh: A symbol is being stolen in plain sight Fight money laundering without punishing small businesses and homebuyers After the Crusades had driven Jews out of Israel, they quickly reentered, creating four long-standing communities. In the 1850s, Jews were the majority of the Jerusalem population.
…
Excerpt limited to ~120 words for fair-use compliance. The full article is at Washington Examiner.
Discussion
0 commentsMore from Washington Examiner
